The popularity of shaving with a straight razor has grown significantly in recent memory. It is widely considered an art form among barbers due to the patience and skill level needed to create the perfect shave with the straight razor.
Where cheaper shaving creams fail is that their lack of quality shines before, during and after the shave. Especially when using a straight razor, cheaper creams can dry the skin out and leave the face full of red-bump irritation, unsightly razor burn and tiny nicks and cuts that sends the user running for the toilet paper to cover their wounds. Creating a high-quality shave with a straight razor takes preparation, skill and the right materials.
In the beginning, it all starts with warming up the face for the shave. Straight razor aficionados suggest using a pre-shave oil to open up the pores and soften the hairs for a smooth shave. But it is the next component that is the most vital, the shaving cream.
The shaving cream works as a lubricant that allows the straight razor to glide across your face rather than dig into the skin, causing painful and unnecessary cuts. Creams also utilize natural oils to keep your face soft and supple to ward off the damage from shaving.
So for fans of the straight razor shave, it is vital to find a high-quality shaving cream that will treat your face right. Here are reviews of the best shaving cream for straight razor shaves.
Best Shaving Cream
Known for their distinct approach to shaving creams, Jack Black has created a terrific cream that works to lift hairs to ensure a close shave every time. The company’s Supreme Cream Triple Cushion Shave Lather features a cream made with macadamia nut oil and soy to produce a refreshing shave. Free of fragrance and other chemicals, the Supreme Cream does a remarkable job reducing that dreaded razor burn and reduces irritation for a better-looking shave.
Whether it be in a mug or bowl, the Supreme Cream turns into a rich and hearty lather in seconds. The cream does really well with a brush for maximum coverage.
The oils within the cream help keep the face lubricated during the shave to prevent cuts but also leaves the skin hydrated and soft hours after the shave is over.
Only Small Amount Needed
Unlike lower-quality creams, the Jack Black Supreme Cream doesn’t take much to work into a lather, making the jar go a long way
- Doesn’t take much cream to work into a thick lather
- Triple Cushion technology does an excellent job at minimizing razor burn as well as irritation.
- Oils in the cream help hydrate face for softer skin
- Cost prohibitive to the bargain seekers, but delivers a top-notch shave
Ideal for lovers of the shaving mug and brush, this cream creates a large amount of lather making it perfect for a full face shave. Light scented, the Supreme Cream won’t overpower you with an off-putting smell. The Jack Black Supreme Cream is specially designed to handle the delicate nature of the straight razor shave.
With a long tradition, the Proraso company has made their mark creating high-quality shaving creams that nourish and moisturize your face during a shave. Their Proraso Shaving Cream is another rich cream that utilizes shea butter to create a smooth and close shave that leaves the skin feeling clean. With just a dime-size amount, the Proraso cream works with a small amount of water to create a lather that will soften your beard.
The shea butter in the cream keeps your skin silky and supple for a less irritating experience from your straight razor shave.
The pleasing scent of Sandalwood Oil leaves your face refreshed and feeling great after a shave. The oil isn’t too overpowering or fragrant.
The shaving cream is rich in emollients to make the beard soft and ready for shaving within minutes of application.
- Doesn’t overpower you with fragrance or smell, pleasing long after shave is complete.
- Skin feels refreshed and invigorated during all phases of the shave.
- Does an admirable job keeping the nicks and cuts down for straight razors.
- Those looking for a more complex cream may be disappointed with the simplicity of the Proraso cream.
For those straight razor shave lovers who prefer a simple shaving cream that does an excellent job working itself into a healthy lather for quality performance then the Proraso Shaving Cream checks all of the boxes. This cream will leave you feeling you satisfied by providing both a pleasing scent and a smooth shave, Affordable and great at protecting your face, the Proraso cream is a winner.
For those straight razor fans who don’t like the cumbersome feel of a lather but want the protection, then Vikings Blade Non-Lather Cream is a really nice alternative. Ideal for use with a shaving mug or bowl, the cream mixes with a little water to thin out the consistency to your liking. Best for shaving with after a shower, the non-lather cream is rich and velvety to the touch producing a shave that is delightful to the touch.
Best for shavers who like the old school feel of a cream that doesn’t create large amounts of lather. The Vikings Blade works well with all kinds of brushes for even application.
Sandalwood & Cedar Smell
The cream leaves a pleasing odor of Sandalwood and Cedar after the shave that is masculine yet doesn’t overpower.
The Vikings Blade does well with keeping your face lubricated during the shave and allowing the face to retain the moisture from the cream long after you have completed your shave.
- Lather evaporates even after use with a mug, allowing the cream to spread evenly.
- For a non-lather cream, it is incredibly slick, keeping your face free of nicks and cuts.
- The container may look small, but the cream goes a very long way.
- Shavers who like a lot of lather with their straight razor shave will be let down by the Vikings Blade.
For an upper tier non-lather shaving cream, the Vikings Blade Luxury Non-Lather Foaming Shaving Cream is an absolute home run. With a smooth, non-greasy feel, this luxury cream will give you a great shave without punishing your skin.
Another luxury shaving cream that goes great with a straight razor is the L’Occitane Cade Shaving Cream. This cream utilizes natural ingredients to help reduce irritation and keep your face looking youthful and hydrated. For those who love a cream that can be used with a mug or bowl, this cream can build a lather that applies smoothly with a brush. One of the more consistent creams we’ve tested, the L’Occitane Cade is a terrific luxury option.
With shea butter as a primary ingredient, the L’Occitane Cade cream refreshes the skin and keeps the razor moving smoothly over the face for a close shave.
Vegetable-based glycerin is coupled with the shea butter to enhance the moisture of the skin without introducing harmful chemicals to the face.
Creamy Base for Smooth Shave
The Cade cream goes on evenly for maximum coverage ensuring a complete shave when using your straight razor.
- The cream does a great job at hydrating the face before and after the shave.
- The all-natural base of the cream assures the shaver’s skin won’t be treated to unnecessary chemicals.
- The base of the cream is rich creating a comforting experience when shaving.
- May be out of the price range for straight razor users but should be considered due to its quality.
What keeps bringing straight razor users back to the Cade cream from L’Occitane is that it is pleasing to the skin as well as the nose. The delightful smell of the Cade is a lasting bonus after providing your face with protection that inhibits irritation and cuts. For a strong luxury shaving cream, the L’Occitane Cade cream is nothing short of spectacular.
Based out of New York City, The Art of Shaving is a brand known for making high performing shave creams that smell nice and do well at protecting your face. When used with a straight razor, the Sandalwood scent of their shaving cream is a particularly gratifying aroma. Boasting a base made with coconut oils and other natural ingredients, this Sandalwood cream doesn’t need much to form a lather on your beard.
Luxury shaving cream typically carries oils in their ingredients, the Sandalwood edition of this cream uses coconut oil to perfection.
Dime-Sized Amount Is All You Need
We were blown away by how little of the Art of Shaving cream we needed to create a boisterous lather that quickly covered the entire shaving area of our face.
Don’t Need a Brush to Apply
Some creams don’t work well unless using a brush, and this cream doesn’t have that problem as we were able to build lather using just our fingertips.
- Can be used with a brush either with water or without, either way, the cream grows lather when using.
- The base is made with coconut and essential oils, leaving the skin hydrated and properly lubricated during the straight razor shave.
- You don’t need much cream to create a healthy lather, so the jar lasts a very long time.
- Scent and price may be off-putting to some shavers, but the quality of the cream is luxury-level.
The Sandalwood scented cream by Art of Shaving is a top-notch cream that is fantastic at lifting the hairs of your beard so that your straight razor can give you a proper shave. Whether you use a brush or not, the cream will quickly become a lather for ideal coverage. One of the best luxury creams we tested, the Sandalwood cream is playing at an elite level.
A favorite of Italian barbers, C. O. Bigelow, has crafted a premium shave cream that promises to leave your skin feeling fresh, hydrated and cool. A water-based cream that features eucalyptus oil and menthol to create a shave that will bring a smile with its distinct sensation to your face. In addition to the great shave, the mid-tier C.O. Bigelow has an affordable price that won’t raise any red flags for your wallet.
The eucalyptus oil in the C.O. Bigelow cream helps with lubricating the face so that the straight razor doesn’t hang up in your beard.
The menthol in the cream provides a cooling sensation that leaves the shaved areas feeling refreshed and hydrated.
With the combination of eucalyptus oil and menthol, the cream is one of the better-scented creams that we tested.
- Great for reducing and minimizing irritation and razor burn.
- The cream cools the skin due to the eucalyptus oil and menthol.
- One tube will last several months, with most users getting six months of cream.
- Due to the eucalyptus and menthol, the cream can cause issues with sensitive skin.
The Premium Shave Cream from C.O. Bigelow is a singular cream that offers a cooling effect not seen in most creams. Excellent at keeping your face clear of the dreaded razor burn, the Premium Shave Cream is a very capable and well-admired shaving cream for your straight razor.
Our choice for the best shaving cream for straight razors on this list is the Jack Black Supreme Cream Triple Cushion Shave Lather. We felt that the cream did a magnificent job at reducing burn and nicks and producing a shave that left us feeling smooth long after we finished.
The lather works well in either a shaving mug or the palm of your hand. We were impressed that we didn’t need much cream to work it into a large amount of lather for our face.
Although it may seem a little steep in price, the Triple Cushion Shave Lather is well worth the cost due to the high performance of the cream. For straight razor users, you certainly don’t want to skimp when it comes to protecting your face, and this cream from Jack Black certainly earns the accolades as the best shaving cream for a straight razor.